DriveThruRPG.com
Browse Categories
$ to $















Back
pixel_trans.gif
Other comments left by this customer:
You must be logged in to rate this
pixel_trans.gif
US Marshals: A Shared Storytelling Game Of Justice In The American Wild West
Publisher: Kids in the Attic
by Harold C. [Verified Purchaser]
Date Added: 05/16/2022 06:26:39

Overall - I had to rate this at 2 stars out of five - not because the writing was bad, or that the author's point of view was objectionable or anything along those lines...

I gave it a low rating largely because the purpose for which I purchased this product was not met.

I'm currently running a campaign set in New Mexico 1867 and one of my player characters was offered a chance to become a territorial deputy. As such, the first words out of the player's mouth were "What are my duties, what laws do I enforce" and other similiar questions.

If you're looking to find answers to those questions - they are sadly lacking in this booklet. I will have to try and find some online resource that explains what laws a territorial marshal is supposed to enforce, where his jurisdiction lies, and what he's supposed to do from time to time. In all? This product may well be worth your while as a game system and what have you, but as a means of fleshing things out, I found it sub-optimal. When specific details matter, this PDF did not meet my needs.



Rating:
[2 of 5 Stars!]
US Marshals: A Shared Storytelling Game Of Justice In The American Wild West
Click to show product description

Add to DriveThruRPG.com Order

pixel_trans.gif
Creator Reply:
Hello Harold C. — Lucus Palosaari here, writer for US Marshals. Thank you for your review and even more for explaining your review. I'm sorry you weren't able to find the level of detail you were looking for. As you have the book, we do make some recommendations in the first chapter for websites, films, and even proper non-fiction books to try checking out if you have the inclination. In our own book, we only really have the ~1,000 words or so on pages 12, 13, & 14 for the "Playing a US Marshal (or Deputy)" chapter and specifically the "Being a United States Marshal (or Deputy Marshal)" section that talks about the more specific types of roles and expectations for a US Marshal. We have a little more information peppered throughout the text beyond the first two chapters, like in the “Gamemastering the Marshals” chapter at the end, and I’m thinking specifically about how we compare US Marshals to each type of NPC in the back and how limited they are in the jurisdiction — but that’s about it. We also talk about how they were paid in a few spots, like “The Problem with Cash” and that stuff gets at what life was like for a US Marshal at least. But our focus was on the "federal" Marshals and how they exist because their own jurisdiction exceeds beyond the borders of a single town (like a Town Marshals would end), a county (like a Sheriff's would end), and beyond even a state's borders to all "US soil." There were Marshals stationed in territories like the Oklahoma or New Mexico Territories but really that was just “where they were based” and under whose direct District Attorney and/or Federal Judge they worked for enforcing federal laws and they would go about their duties described in the book going wherever needed (Bass Reeves was famous for going to great lengths “to get his Man” etc.). We didn’t elucidate many of the specific federal laws (though we talked about how things like “train robbing wasn’t federal UNLESS you stole mail” etc.) because we assumed the Gamemaster could and would know what they should be and they’re the kind of “big ones” in general (murder, theft, etc.). Thank you again for your review, good luck finding the information you’re looking for.
pixel_trans.gif
Hudson City: The Urban Abyss - PDF
Publisher: Hero Games
by Harold C. [Verified Purchaser]
Date Added: 01/08/2021 02:19:41

In all, the product would have received a 4 star rating. The editing was GOOD, the presentation was GOOD, and the layout was GOOD. Toss in the fact that the detailed information contained within was GOOD, and you'd see why I'd rate it at a good SOLID 4 star product. If you want to run a campaign set in a gritty urban environment, this would be a worth while product.

The problem is, the security restrictions placed on the PDF document by means of internal document security - was higher than any I have ever used from other game companies such as SJGames, R. Talsorian, etc. Security settings folllow these guidelines (right click on PDF page, select properties, then security to see what the security settings are for your PDF).

Printing Document Assembly Content Copying Content Copying for Accessibility Page Extraction Commenting FIlling of form fields Signing Creation of Template pages

SJGames for example, only disallows Document Assembly and Page Extraction. R Talsorian only disallows Document Assembly, Page Extraction and Creation of Template pages. This particular product?

Disalllows EVERYTHING save for Printing and Content Copying for Accessibility.

How did I discover this fact? I went to copy the word "otorhinolaryngology" so I could google its meaning. When I could not copy and paste the word to Google's search field, is when I dug deeper into the permissions at the security level and thought to myself "Wow" and said to myself "not going to buy another product again with this kind of restriction."



Rating:
[2 of 5 Stars!]
Hudson City: The Urban Abyss - PDF
Click to show product description

Add to DriveThruRPG.com Order

pixel_trans.gif
Displaying 1 to 2 (of 2 reviews) Result Pages:  1 
pixel_trans.gif
pixel_trans.gif Back pixel_trans.gif
0 items
 Gift Certificates